Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Houston Wood's avatar

I like so much of this. And agree with the overall argument. But a couple of quibbles, in good faith.

1) I don't think any future ever "belongs to anyone." There may be winners and losers, but no one owns the future. And everyone, even the invading genocide wielding settlers, struggles.

2) You suggest: "The question isn't whether AI will change everything. It already is." Already is changing everything? People's long term relationships seem to be not changing at all, at least among those I know. And for many of us, our long term relationships are the most important part of life.

Most jobs haven't much changed either, and those that require handy hands aren't likely to change for quite some time (fix your fridge? trim your trees?). The lives of let's say about 3 billion people on Earth are not much changing.

So yes, we who read you and write here are changing mightily, I agree, and we suspect we are in the vanguard. But most of the people I know don't really want me to talk about this stuff with them partly because they have not seen any substantial changes in their lives as yet. And some are resisting what changes seem to be offered to them, in principle, as they detest AI. (e.g. my 22 year old daughter!)

I guess I'm just suggesting we should slow down in our use of "everyone," "we" and "all" until we make sure we're not just talking about privileged Global North and educated people with leisure time to read and write about this stuff.

And, as I said, these are quibbles only! I endorse your exhortations for us in this discourse world.

Expand full comment
Ida K's avatar

Yes, yes, yes!! Our brains are wired to perceive the unfamiliar as a dangerous predator. Instead of looking at what might be born. We resent our current conditions while simultaneously r bodies and lizard brains r addicted to them. But what if we embraced the possibility that this current uncertainty might be an opportunity to reshape the very conditions we’ve been born into that have felt so limiting and suffocating to so many of us?

Expand full comment
23 more comments...

No posts